Ethereal-dev: Re: [ethereal-dev] Ethereal and H.323 dissector possible license solutio

Note: This archive is from the project's previous web site, ethereal.com. This list is no longer active.

Date: Mon, 18 Sep 2000 09:26:35 +0200
> > The page at
> >
> > 	http://www.gnu.org/philosophy/license-list.html
> >
> > lists the MPL amongs the licenses that are not compatible with the GPL.

F*CK! (Sorry, but this license thing is getting to me :-( )

I predict that the GPL will eventually prevent some seriously useful 
applications seeing the light of day.... Pity...

> > but, if not, I'm certainly willing to grant the exception.

Thanks!

> The problem with GPL + exception licences is that they are rarely if
> ever GPL compatible themselves. Therefore changing ethereal to a
> GPL + exception licence makes it impossible to import GPL code to
> use in the dissectors.

Hmmmm, most of the network related stuff is usually BSD-ish, right?

> An oft mooted proposal is to contact the author of imported code for
> permission. This works but imposses extra weight on the maintainer.

True, but since Ethereal is for the largest part code done by just a 
couple (5,6?) people, it's not (yet?) a problem... Once it's policy, 
the problem ends.

> BTW Andreas: is the code you have used likely to be dual licences in
> the near future?

I'd love to, but since the code I use is created by a company 
that donated it to an open source project (OpenH323), and that company
is also using it for it's own non-free products I doubt that it will 
ever get GPL-ed...

-- 
Andreas Sikkema
andreas.sikkema@xxxxxxxxxxx
"Standing barefoot in a river of clues, most people would 
         not get their toes wet." - Brian Kantor in a.s.r.